Rage Against the Machine beat X Factor winner in charts

wozzo

Inactive User
Joined
Dec 30, 2006
Messages
1,777
Reaction score
66
Rock band Rage Against The Machine has won the most competitive battle in years for the Christmas number one.

The band's single, Killing In The Name, sold 500,000 downloads beating X Factor winner Joe McElderry's The Climb by 50,000 copies to clinch the top spot.

Their success followed a Facebook campaign designed to prevent another X Factor number one.

One retailer said it was a "truly remarkable outcome - possibly the greatest chart upset ever".

'Sterile pop'

Speaking on the Radio 1 chart show, Zack de la Rocha from Rage said: "We are very, very ecstatic about being number one."

He added it was an "incredible organic grassroots campaign".

_46922780_zack226_bbc.jpg


"It says more about the spontaneous action taken by young people throughout the UK to topple this very sterile pop monopoly," he said.

McElderry, 18, praised the campaign, adding: "It's been exciting to be part of a much-hyped battle and they definitely deserve congratulations."

Thanking all the fans who bought his single, he said: "This time last year I never thought for one minute that I'd win The X Factor, never mind about having a debut single out, so I'm just delighted to be in the charts.

CHART ANALYSIS
Colin Paterson
Colin Paterson, BBC News entertainment reporter

It is simply one of the biggest shocks in chart history.

The common belief was that the race for Christmas number one had been destroyed by the X Factor.

For the last four years the winning act has been top of the festive charts by a landslide. Bookmakers only took bets on who would be number two.

This year the corporate might of Simon Cowell has been defeated by a husband and wife's Facebook campaign.

The result is 'Killing In The Name', which most parents would be pretty reluctant to play to their children. It contains 17 uses of the F-word.

This chart shock is right up there with Spiller's 'Groovejet' derailing the start of Victoria Beckham's non-Spice Career in 2000 or crooner Engelbert Humperdink ending The Beatles' run of 11 number ones in a row.

Two other points - this could become an annual event - the public deciding on a track with which to take on the X Factor winner.

Secondly there is still every chance Joe will reach number one next week.

The Rage Against Machine campaign was designed for one week only so Joe could get the top spot, saving him the indignity of being the first ever X Factor winner not to hit number one with their debut single.

Have Your Say: What does Rage's victory mean for X Factor?

"It's been such an incredible couple of months and I got the best Christmas gift I could ever have asked for in winning The X Factor."

Despite earlier in the week calling the campaign "stupid", X Factor judge Simon Cowell offered his congratulations to the couple behind it, Jon and Tracy Morter.

He said: "I am gutted for Joe because a number one single meant a lot to him but I have to congratulate Jon and Tracy, who started the Facebook campaign.

"I called Jon on Saturday to congratulate the two of them that, win or lose, they turned this into a very exciting race for the Christmas number one.

"I am proud of Joe - he worked really hard this week, but he has a great year ahead of him."

The Los Angeles rock band's hit also set two records: it is the first single to reach the top of the charts on download sales alone and has achieved the biggest download sales total in a first week ever in the UK charts.

McElderry's song was only released digitally after his victory in the X Factor, giving it less time to rack up sales than Rage Against The Machine.

On Friday the band's lead was just 9,000 copies, but sales then soared by 200,000 to secure victory.

Official Charts Company managing director Martin Talbot said: "Congratulations to Rage Against The Machine on their number one - as we have seen in recent years, overhauling any X Factor winner in the race for the Christmas number one is no mean achievement."

Free concert

Rage Against The Machine are signed to Epic Records, which is part of Sony BMG, the same label as McElderry.

Mr de la Rocha said the band would perform a free concert in the UK in 2010 to celebrate their chart win.

The past four Christmas number ones have all been by X Factor winners; Alexandra Burke's version of Hallelujah last year was one of the biggest selling festive singles ever.

Joe McElderry
Eighteen-year-old McElderry won X Factor last Sunday

Guitarist Tom Morello said it had "tapped into the silent majority of the people in the UK who are tired of being spoon-fed one schmaltzy ballad after another".

He added that proceeds from the single would go to homeless charity Shelter tying in with the Morters' Facebook campaign which includes an online link to give to the charity, raising nearly £70,000 so far.

Gennaro Castaldo, from high street retailer HMV, said it was a "truly remarkable outcome - possibly the greatest chart upset ever".


RECENT CHRISTMAS NUMBER ONES
2000: Bob the Builder: Can We Fix It
2001: Robbie Williams & Nicole Kidman: Somethin' Stupid
2002: Girls Aloud: Sound of the Underground
2003: Michael Andrews feat Gary Jules: Mad World
Band Aid 20: Do They Know It's Christmas?
2005: Shayne Ward: That's My Goal
2006: Leona Lewis: A Moment Like This
2007: Leon Jackson: When You Believe
2008: Alexandra Burke: Hallelujah

What's all the Rage against?

"It's not so much that Joe lost the race - sales of his single have matched those of recent X Factor winners, and he shouldn't take this personally; this is all about the stunning impact of the Rage Against The Machine internet campaign in galvanising music fans to protest against the dominance of the reality show in recent years."

The expletive-laden song is a "powerful protest", he said, adding: "Rage Against The Machine may not be the ideal expression of the Christmas spirit - and many people will have preferred a more appropriate song to top the festive charts, but their anti-corporate message proved a perfect vehicle through which to register such a powerful protest."

The last big Christmas battle on a similar scale was between the Spice Girls' Goodbye and South Park character Chef's Chocolate Salty Balls in 1998. The Spice Girls won with 380,000 to their rival's 375,000.

Despite losing out on the single top spot, Cowell kept a hold on the album chart, with Susan Boyle's I Dreamed A Dream remaining at number one for a fourth week.
 
i think this has to be the most pathetic campaign ever in history
 
Whilst I agree that the song probably does not deserve to be no1 for Christmas I fully agree with the campaign to stop karaoke singers from being no1 for christmas, just because they won a singing competition.

If they were good enough they would be able to make it without winning a competition.

The contrast between these karaoke singers and the stars that appear on the show is very evident. I will admit that Leona is a cut above, but I beleive that she would still have made it without the X.

The show is set up to exploit the acts that can't sing just by showing them on TV.
They then exploit the acts that are never going to be good enough because they want 24 acts for their bootcamp.

Most of all they exploit the British public by getting them to spend millions of pounds every week with their phone voting. (very nice for Simon though to swell his bank account).
 
2007: Leon Jackson: When You Believe

what a success !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

weres he now???


same will happen to McEldrey (i hope)
 
2007: Leon Jackson: When You Believe

what a success !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

weres he now???


same will happen to McEldrey (i hope)

Leon Jackson never recovered after his meteoric rise to fame followed by his monumental crash to obscurity after his one-hit wonder Christmas single.

This photo was taken shortly afterwards outside his family home in Blackburn, West Lothian.

drunk_santa.jpg
 
I agree with langland
A stand had to be made although i thing a better choise could have been made
 
i think this has to be the most pathetic campaign ever in history

And why is that?

its great that the public have spoken and said screw you x factor.

Did you buy the x factor crap thats why you think its pathetic ?
 
Leon Jackson never recovered after his meteoric rise to fame followed by his monumental crash to obscurity after his one-hit wonder Christmas single.

This photo was taken shortly afterwards outside his family home in Blackburn, West Lothian.

drunk_santa.jpg

PMSL...

some people made the point in the papers today that the record is about not conforming and yet people have bought it after being told to buy it!

Another is that its a ploy by Sony to get people to actually buy rather than illegally download both records - both of which they get profits from.
 
The song might not be the best no1 but the message it has is clear but i doubt Cowell will give a toss.
He is still in control and will sign a new deal with ITV and next year will condemn us all to more sugar pop shit sang by a kareoke singer who has the shelf life and brain power of a lettuce.
So we might end up next year with a similar situation and once again the Xmas no1 will be settled in a battle and not through the usual ways.

There is nothing like religion to bring on a good war.
Personally i never listen to chart music and its the missus that likes the x factor so its irrelevant to me but my spine always curls when i see one of these clowns on the television.

ITV seem hell bent in paying Simon Cowell and that mutt Jordan aka Katie Price aka Pig in knickers aka waste of heart and lungs, millions of pounds to contaminate our brains with their latest crap.
:grrrr:
 
i love the song.

however, it was more to do with the fact of NOT having x-factor at number one. the way they time the show so it finishes on the saturday, single released on the monday, charts on the sunday - you could almost call it rigging it to be number 1. proper swizz.

mums and dads bought the x-factor single, kids bought the rage one.
 
I was lucky enough to have a childhood in the 1970's so it was always good to find out who had made it to N°1

Here's some examples:

1973 Slade "Merry Xmas Everybody"
1974 Mud "Lonely This Christmas"
1975 Queen "Bohemian Rhapsody"
1976 Johnny Mathis "When A Child Is Born (Soleado)"
1977 Wings "Mull of Kintyre"
1978 Boney M "Mary's Boy Child" / "Oh My Lord"

And we shouldn't forget the great Christmas tunes that never made the top spot but made Christmas special.

Mike Oldfield - In Dulci Jubilo
Roy Wood - Wish it could be Christmas everyday
Greg Lake - I Believe In Father Christmas
Chris De Burgh - A Spaceman Came Travelling
Frankie Goes To Hollywood - The Power Of Love
Jona Lewie - Stop The Cavalry
Kirsty McCall & The Pouges - Fairy tale of New York

All far better than the pish we get hit with thesde days!
 
And why is that?

its great that the public have spoken and said screw you x factor.

Did you buy the x factor crap thats why you think its pathetic ?
Havent bought music for years lol the reason i think its pathetic is there are more serious issues out there than who gets to number 1 for xmas,the only Winner was SONY lol .Hasn`t simon cowell got something to do with a part of the sony record label so he didn`t lose any money lol as for xfactor its just glorified karaoke for tv anyway merry christmas
 
Havent bought music for years lol the reason i think its pathetic is there are more serious issues out there than who gets to number 1 for xmas,the only Winner was SONY lol .Hasn`t simon cowell got something to do with a part of the sony record label so he didn`t lose any money lol as for xfactor its just glorified karaoke for tv anyway merry christmas

Yep, I believe Cowell scored twice the wonga over this? Laughing all the way to bank!

Heard something on the radio the other day saying as much anyway...?
 
RIGHT!!! I've had enough of this Sony/Cowell crap.

How about supporting the little people next time.

Anyone heard of Rough Trade Records...namely the Rigid Digits label?

Anyway, here's a REAL Christmas song for ya...

HANX!!!

[ame]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y_N_Vj5ISWo[/ame]
 
i think this has to be the most pathetic campaign ever in history


Too bad.

It stopped the Simon Cowell pop piss machine that has ruined the Christmas charts for years and has started a musical revolution in my eyes.

I love the fact that a revolutionist/protest/rock/metal band where a Xmas number one almost 20 years after it's initial release.

As much as I love 'Rage against the Machine' (I really do), next year I'll be starting a campaign to get SLADE's 'Merry Christmas Everyone' to the top.

It gives me faith in humainty.

:)
 
Last edited:
OMG . Sounds like a band i was in when i was 14 lol
Baheed I'd forgotten about those numbers . What a good selection of xmas songs that was
 
OMG . Sounds like a band i was in when i was 14 lol

lol :)

It's not everyones choice, and it's definately not their best song.

It's a bullet in the head for the control of the media.

Yeah!

lol
 
RIGHT!!! I've had enough of this Sony/Cowell crap.

How about supporting the little people next time.

Anyone heard of Rough Trade Records...namely the Rigid Digits label?

Anyway, here's a REAL Christmas song for ya...

HANX!!!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y_N_Vj5ISWo

Ohh yeH Seedy thats the bollox and whilst we are on the subject here is my xmas no1.lol

[ame]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XiSSkPHpzP8&feature=PlayList&p=93AF8FD250E7CC0E&playnext=1&playnext_from=PL&index=32[/ame]
 
Ohh yeH Seedy thats the bollox and whilst we are on the subject here is my xmas no1.lol

Nice...I remember when they made it onto Top of the Pops with Dead Cities.

They were on the broo at the time & someone from the office spotted them & cut their money. Watty & Big John could hardly blend into a crowd LoL

One of their guitarists (Gogs), is involved in a youth group up this way, my youngest has been working on a song written by him.
 
Back
Top