So this is justice?

RAB - P

VIP Member
VIP Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2004
Messages
11,038
Reaction score
1,425
Location
The Penny Arcade
2257617690.jpg
149431577.jpg


One is Osama Bin Laden’s right-hand man in Europe, a “truly dangerous individual” wanted on terrorism charges in eight countries.

The other is a 10-year-old Glasgow schoolgirl who likes X Factor and playing with dogs. The UK Government is about to deport one of them – and it isn’t the al Qaeda man.

Palestinian Abu Qatada has been told he can’t be sent back to his native Jordan, even though authorities there have promised not to torture him. Such a move would, apparently, breach his human rights.

No, the foreign national the Home Office has in its sights is Precious Mhango, a little girl who has spent all but the first three years of her life in this country. She is being repatriated to Malawi with her mother Florence; to a country she can’t remember, where she doesn’t speak the language and where she is at real risk of genital mutilation.

Her crime? Precious is being deported because her mum, Florence, left an abusive husband.

The pair would have been allowed to stay in Britain if they had stuck with the man, who has leave to remain in the UK. They are only being thrown out because they were not prepared to put up with domestic violence.

The stories of Abu Qatada and Precious Mhango pretty much sum up how bizarre the UK’s asylum and immigration policies have become over recent years.

There are countless examples of criminals or even terrorists being told they can stay; and of deserving individuals being told they must go.

The system has got to be made fairer. At least that is what the UK’s new deputy prime minister said three years ago. Nick Clegg, then very much in opposition with little hope of ever gaining power, blasted the then Labour government on refugees.

“The attitude of a government towards asylum seekers reveals a great deal about its moral compass,” he said. “The issue is not whether a government is ‘tough’ enough on asylum seekers.

“It is whether we are able to separate justified pleas for asylum from unjustified claims, deal speedily and efficiently with those who are not justified and with compassion and humanity towards those who are.”

Clegg then attacked Labour for expanding its so-called “White List” – a group of countries that it would almost automatically refuse asylum from. Malawi was one of the new additions.

Last week Clegg moved to stop locking up children facing deportation. That may have kept Precious, who has had two periods of detention, from behind bars. Ironically, it may also have speeded up her removal.

Mr Clegg and Home Secretary Theresa May – a champion of the victims of domestic violence while in opposition – may now wish to consult their moral compass while thinking about some of the people allowed to stay in Britain while Precious goes.

Take Courtney Burry, a Jamaican-born paedophile now living close to two primary schools in Dumbarton.

To be fair, the Home Office would like to throw him out. But Burry has battled deportation for 12 years, with the costs of his numerous appeals and ongoing monitoring now believed to amount to £400,000.

Or Abu Hamza. Again, the authorities would like to strip the hook-handed preacher of hate of his British passport.

But, currently awaiting extradition to the US in Belmarsh prison, the Egyptian-born fundamentalist has, unlike Precious, been able to use the court system to keep himself safely in Britain. There are, of course, real legal and human rights concerns about sending men like Qatada and Hamza to other countries.

Can we believe, say, the Jordanians when they say they won’t torture Qatada – or use evidence against him from those who have been tortured?

But are these concerns really greater than those facing Precious?

It isn’t just that a 10-year-old brought up in Glasgow will not thrive in the country of her birth. She will almost certainly be split from her mum – Malawian custom dictates that the children of a marriage belong to the father. Moreover, her supporters argue that in Malawi her education will end and she will be married at 12. Is that not torture too?

Westminster, as Clegg said, wants to be seen to “get tough” on those it wants to turn out. Its victims have tended not to be the Abu Qatadas and Abu Hamzas of the world. And those falling foul of Britain’s rigour on immigration aren’t always from the kind of poverty-stricken nations associated with asylum.

American writer Thomas Legendre was forced to leave Edinburgh after failing to prove that, as a self-employed novelist, he earned enough money to support himself. He had to take up a job in England.

Another American, Angela Faye Smith, was last year told she had to leave her home in Arbroath – and her children – after she split from her husband. Smith eventually won her case, but only after horrific stress.

Anne McLaughlin, the Glasgow MSP leading the battle for Precious, yesterday said: “I don’t think people realise just how unfair our asylum system is. It needs to be fair and it needs to be seen to be fair.”


MP fights the case for Precious

Glasgow MP Margaret Curran has met with UK Borders Agency officers to discuss Florence and Precious’ case.

Last month, Ms Curran wrote to Home Secretary Theresa May asking her to grant them leave to remain in their Cranhill home.

However, after failing to receive a response, Ms Curran decided to arrange the meeting with UKBA officers.

The meeting took place last Friday, as it was decided that the pair were refused grounds to appeal the last court ruling that said the Home Office was justified to have them deported.

A spokeswoman for the Glasgow East MP said: “Margaret stressed the need for compassion to be shown given the years this mother and daughter have been in Glasgow, and that this is the city that Precious calls home.

“She also argued that all relevant circumstances must be taken into account, such as the domestic violence Florence previously suffered.”
 

stevie1ball

Inactive User
Joined
Jun 11, 2009
Messages
1,128
Reaction score
8
Location
Soaring above the clouds
It's ridiculous how these two cases can be seen to be so different to the eyes of the justice system, and once again the most serious threat to a child's future is overlooked whilst the life of a no good air breathing Taliban extremist is accepted as being more important.

I hope the power of the Scottish MP is strong enough to prevent this from happening.
 

Bronto

Global Moderator
Staff member
Moderator
Joined
Nov 17, 2001
Messages
12,276
Reaction score
2,584
This Government (Tory, Labour. Liberal - their all the same) are Cowards, plain and simple cowards, they take the easy option every time, Qatada is a known Terrorist and should be sent back, I would say that if Jordan Tortured him that would be a bonus of he's deportation

When you see things like this we should hang our heads in shame, proud to be British ? paa !! I'm truly embarrassed to be associated with this shit hole of a country
 

oneman

VIP Member
VIP Member
Joined
Aug 23, 2007
Messages
7,504
Reaction score
1,283
Location
Essex
So basically if a woman comes to the UK, all she need do is get married and she is entitled to automatic citizenship ?

What about Gary McKinnon, he is basically a terrorist in the eyes of the US so why is he being protected.
 

TheCheekyMonkey

Inactive User
Joined
Jul 15, 2007
Messages
1,349
Reaction score
85
Location
on my way to brum brum
too true, i mean the justice system is fooked, we know that , and the immigration system is just as bad, we know that, however in cases like these you just cant help but think thats there other forces moving in the background..........

as anyone in there right mind, and with an ounce of common sense, dignity and pride would see that keepig that shiitbag here isnt against his human rights, its against ours!.

i mean c`mon, its meant to be our `peers` who make these decisions...................sack the lot of em. I dont want terrorist attacks, but i cant help but think that if some of these extremists started blowing up a few MPs, Lords and ladys then things might start happening quicker..............
 

emarald

Inactive User
Joined
Mar 13, 2008
Messages
1,944
Reaction score
592
So basically if a woman comes to the UK, all she need do is get married and she is entitled to automatic citizenship ?

No she has to remain married for x amount of time and live here 3 years uninterrupted.
That would be 3 years after her marriage.then she can apply for UK citizenship.

It would seem they are not British citizen.


What about Gary McKinnon, he is basically a terrorist in the eyes of the US so why is he being protected.

Not sure why this is mentioned.
Gary McKinnon is a British citizen.
 
Last edited:

oneman

VIP Member
VIP Member
Joined
Aug 23, 2007
Messages
7,504
Reaction score
1,283
Location
Essex
No she has to remain married for x amount of time and live here 3 years uninterrupted.
That would be 3 years after her marriage.then she can apply for UK citizenship.

It would seem they are not British citizen.

I know she could have applied after 5 years of marriage which I presume that she did not have. I guess it depends on what sort of visa she had before the marriage. If it was a leave of indefinate stay then she would be allowed to stay here. If not then she faces deportation.

I understand conditions where she could get deported to are not great but unfortunately they do not count for political aslyum.
 

Raven24

Banned
Joined
Jan 18, 2010
Messages
1,186
Reaction score
22
Location
Lost In HD.
Completely fooked.

I think in situations like this with these stories leaking out the government need to be more candid and forthcoming because I'm trying to find a logical answer here why the terrorist stays and the little girl goes....but I cannot find it.....also if the gov are there essentially to do our bidding then why do they constantly make the outrageous decision and more to the point why do we as a whole stand for it time after time ? I never understood that.

Wouldn't surprise me if the gov are getting their pockets lined by giving these terrorists a comfy life - then the thing that the little girl did wrong was the fact that she hasn't taken up terrorism and that her mum did the right thing.

It's bullshit, plain and simple.
 

dj999

Inactive User
Joined
Apr 24, 2008
Messages
817
Reaction score
28
Location
birmingham
its a just a big **** up. send that hooker back.
 
TEST
Top